lots of change - all to start my 3rd redo

worker-toolkit-potion-polyglot/.claude/skills/detector-rubric-form/SKILL.md

@@ -1,73 +0,0 @@
----
-name: detector-rubric-form
-description: |
-  Self-check that your atomic rubric is well-formed. A deterministic contract
-  checks the artifact: the file parses against the criterion schema,
-  ids are kebab-case and unique, category and
-  severity use the defined vocabularies, extra_credit criteria carry no
-  severity, at most 2 criteria are crux, `dimensions` names grading-standard
-  criteria, and no text states a numeric penalty amount. A judgment layer
-  checks the writing: each guideline is one positively phrased,
-  independently judgeable requirement, criteria stand alone, factual
-  criteria carry their answer key inline in bold, and elaborations clarify
-  the guideline instead of adding requirements. Reads
-  `tests/atomic-rubric.yaml` (or `tests/rubrics.yaml`) and
-  `tests/grader-context.md`. Emits `not-applicable` when the task has no
-  atomic rubric yet.
-allowed-tools: Bash, Read, Write
----
-
-# Rubric-form detector
-
-This skill checks your atomic rubric as an artifact. Each criterion is scored
-on its own, and the aggregate score is computed from `category` and
-`severity`. That only works when the file obeys the schema and each criterion
-states one requirement a grader can judge independently.
-
-The failure shapes to catch:
-
-- **Schema violations.** The file fails to parse, ids repeat or are not
-  kebab-case, a category or severity value is outside the vocabulary, an
-  extra_credit criterion carries a severity, more than 2 criteria are crux,
-  or `dimensions` is empty.
-- **Numeric penalty language.** A guideline, elaboration, or
-  `tests/grader-context.md` sentence states a penalty amount, such as
-  "subtract roughly 0.35". Penalty weight is expressed through category and
-  severity. Sizing the subtraction is the grading machinery's job.
-- **Negation-phrased guidelines.** A guideline says "should not" or "must
-  not" instead of stating the requirement positively. Use "The response
-  should avoid X" for prohibitions.
-- **Bundled or fragmentary criteria.** One criterion packs several
-  independent requirements, so a grader must improvise a partial verdict.
-  Or a criterion cannot be judged without reading a sibling criterion.
-  Parallel facts from one derivation may share a criterion.
-- **Missing answer keys.** A criterion grades the response for surfacing a
-  specific fact, and the fact is not stated inline in bold in the guideline.
-- **Requirements hidden in elaborations.** An elaboration adds a requirement
-  the guideline never states.
-- **Unfair grading shapes.** Criteria spent on trivially-satisfied
-  properties, two criteria that both fire on one defect with no note saying
-  which one charges, phrasing that forecloses an approach the rubric's own
-  text treats as acceptable, or a requirement the task's environment cannot
-  satisfy.
-
-Read these before deciding:
-
-1. `.claude/skills/_detector-worker-shell.md` — where to write the report and how to handle re-runs.
-2. `.claude/skills/detector-rubric-form/core.md` — the deterministic contract with its pattern sweeps, the judgment checks, what is deliberately not a finding, verdict definitions, and the body schema.
-
-Compose the report per the schema in `core.md` and write it per `_detector-worker-shell.md`.
-
-## Acting on the verdict
-
-- **`clear`** — the file passes the deterministic contract and the criteria
-  read as a working rubric. Good.
-- **`minor-issues`** — the contract passes, and the findings are
-  polish-level. Read the findings list and tighten the criteria. There is no
-  need to rebuild the rubric.
-- **`material-issues`** — the file breaks the deterministic contract, or at
-  least one criterion cannot be graded as written. Fix every finding in the
-  deterministic-contract section first, then the judgment findings. Re-run
-  this skill after editing.
-- **`not-applicable`** — the task has no atomic rubric yet. Write the atomic
-  rubric first, then come back to this skill.